The recent “Declaration 2018” about illegal immigration caused a stir in Germany. JLH has put together a summary of the brouhaha, including a translation of an essay by Henryk Broder.
The Media Are the Message
by JLH
On March 15, 2018 (six days before the French Intellectuals’ declaration) the following Declaration 2018 appeared in Germany. Reading the original signers, you will recognize at least a few names. Thereafter, the statement was thrown open to further signatories, and a very great number added their names. See here.
Declaration 2018
With increasing dismay, we watch as Germany is damaged by illegal mass immigration. We join with those who demonstrate peacefully for the restoration of constitutional order at the border of our land.
Original Signatories:
Henryk M. Broder
Uwe Tellkamp
Dr. Thilo Sarrazin
Jörg Friedrich
Dr. Jörg Bernig
Matthias Matussek
Vera Lengsfeld
Prof. Egon Flaig
Heimo Schwilk
Ulrich Schacht
Dr. Frank Böckelmann
Herbert Ammon
Thomas-Jürgen Muhs
Sebastian Hennig
Dr. Till Kinzel
Krisztina Koenen
Anabel Schunke
Alexander Wendt
Dr. Ulrich Fröschle
Dr. Karlheinz Weissmann
Thorsten Hinz
Michael Klonovsky
Eberhard Sens
Matthias Moosdorf
Dieter Stein
Frank W. Haubold
Andreas Lombard
Annette Heinisch
Klaus Kelle
Eva Herman
Prof. Max Otte
Two weeks later, on March 29, 2018, the first of the original signers, Henryk Broder, wrote this comment — a typically snarky, broderish romp through the German media and “commenterati. From Die Achse des Guten:
Declaration 2018: Germany Freaks Out
I hesitated a little before signing the “Common Declaration 2018.” It seemed too general, too friendly, too unengaged. I thought the discussion was further advanced. There was a report of the Bundestag’s scientific service, which left the question of the constitutional basis for the opening of the borders unanswered. Previously Horst Seehofer [Bavaria’s CSU leader] had caused nation-wide consternation when — in an interview with the Passauer Neue Presse — he spoke of a “reign of injustice,” referring to an opinion of constitutional expert, Udo di Fabio, who maintained that the government had a duty to protect the German border. “There is no internationally sanctioned obligation of unlimited acceptance of victims of civil war or national collapse.” Rather, the Federal Republic “is duty-bound to re-establish effective control of the national borders, if the general European system of border security and immigration is temporarily or permanently dysfunctional.” Anyone interested in the legal implications was acquainted with a decision of the Regional Superior Court in Koblenz in February, 2017, which established clearly that “illegal entry to the area of the Federal Republic” is “at the moment no longer legally prosecuted.” In this respect, “legal order in the Federal Republic has been deactivated for approximately one and one-half years.”
Against this background, the “Common Declaration 2018” is of a downright touching harmlessness. Like the first sentence in Article 1 of the Golden Rule, “What you don’t want someone else to do to you, don’t do that to anyone else.” Okay, I thought, it’s not the best, it’s not the beginning of undoing the Gordian Knot, but maybe it’s the lowest common denominator acceptable to a few people who are concerned about the erosion of the rule of law. So I signed.
I had anticipated everything possible, but not the storm of outrage that broke out. As if a couple of nutcases had demanded rebuilding the internal German wall or introducing sharia in Bavaria. Starting with one of my industrious biographers, who caught me off guard, and on to the flagship of political correctness in Germany [Die Zeit], where people were surprised at “Who-all is signing Declaration 2018,” e.g. “ministerial undersecretaries and plastic surgeons,” that is, exactly those people who are prized by Die Zeit as subscribers and readers.
It was, you could say in all modesty, a tempest in a teapot. Expressed positively, it was a festival of freedom of opinion, even though it sounded as if the participants were all about doing away with it. Here is an incomplete but quite representative selection of voices: