You can’t insult Germans by calling them a race of dogs, because Germans aren’t a recognizably distinct group within Germany — not like Turks, Kurds, Arabs, Africans, and all the other threads of the rich rainbow tapestry that gives Germany its glorious multicultural diversity.
Here’s the report from Junge Freiheit. Many thanks to Nash Montana for the translation.
Germans can be called “mutt race”
HAMBURG. The office of the district attorney has rejected a notification against the Turkish parents’ union for sedition and slander/insult of Germans. On his Facebook page the former Chairperson of the Turkish parents’ union in Hamburg, Malik Karabulut — according to the NDR last October — insulted Germans as “mutt race”, among other things [Köterrasse: The word Köter is a disparaging word for dog, used for mutt, unclean, subhuman].
“From their hands Jewish blood still flows. There has been worldwide not another people that has had so much disdain for human beings, that has massacred and humiliated them like (Germans),” Karabulut avers. “Does Turkey still expect good things from this dog clan? Do not have expectations Turkey, use power! They have only swinishness on their minds. May God destroy their home territory.”
The Armenian resolution as the starting cause
The starting cause for the Turkish functionaries angry temper tantrum was a resolution by the Bundestag that had classified the murder of people of Armenia as genocide. “This whore by the name of Germany has declared war — and we are still silent,” said Karabulut in outrage. “From now on you are going to get what’s coming to you, you mutt race.” Later the functionary apologized for his choice of words.
The office of the district attorney in Hamburg cannot see sedition or hate speech in Karabulut’s utterances. The attacked group had to stand out “through some strong outer or inner distinguishing characteristic, feature, mark, as a recognizable entity from the outside,” it said in a statement which was made available to Junge Freiheit. But this does not just apply for the description “German”, since this can’t be defined as “a distinguishable part of the whole of the population”.
Germans are not “recognizable as a distinguishable group”
According to the office of the district attorney Germans are not recognizable as a distinguishable group: “Persons with German citizenship are the majority of the population” and therefore they aren’t a “part of the population”. Also, as a collective Germans are “not insultable”, since they are not “a relatively small, in the view of the individuality of its members, an actual comprehensible circle of people,” it further said.
The Turkish parents’ union is a lobbying organization of Turkish parents that according to their website is “against assimilation” and sees only “integration” then, when someone “speaks the language of the majority citizenry, holds themselves to the laws of the land and as far as possible follows societal norms.” The union, according to its own words, has committed itself to fight “categorically against all kinds of discrimination by race, language, religion or sex”.
Oh… OK..I am a true European MUTT and not a drop of German blood.
And you know what, I love K9s. I get along with animals just fine.
There was time when people spoke of the Deutsche Raum which takes in Austria, Germany and a few other places like South Tyrol in Italy and maybe across in to the CS Republic a little way.
Somebody better tell Malik Karabulut that most Muslims, and I assume he is one, have been in love with Germany since WW2.
First of all, the ridiculous charge and more ridiculous rationale point out the destructiveness of laws limiting insults. Like any bureaucracy, the government agencies get captured by those whom they are supposed to regulate, and spend their time afterwards in protecting their clients from competition.
In this case, the clients are the Muslims and the competition is any non-Muslim or anti-Muslim point of view.
As far as the Armenian Genocide, the less said by Germany the better. The German general staff, an official World War I ally of Turkey, was instrumental in providing the staff work for the genocide. But, the last thing we need now is another frenzy of German self-guilt. The Germans can make general amends for all past abuses by losing their guilt and providing a truly safe environment for Armenian and non-Armenian Jews and native Germans. Let the historians and identity groups provide their own memorials.
If Germans are a mutt race, Turks are their parasites.
Malik Karabulut’s repulsive rant proves, yet again, that MENA migrants to European countries retain their identity as that of their country of origin. It doesn’t matter if they have a German passport or were born in Germany, they will never be Germans: always Turks, Moroccans, Arabs. And don’t ever expect them to be grateful to Germany for having given them an immeasurably better quality of life, material standard of living, health care system, education system, etc.
Quote: “Persons with German citizenship are the majority of the population” and therefore they aren’t a “part of the population”.
For a mathematician (I am a physicist), this line of argument is wrong. Germans are a strict subset of the population of Germany, because:
1) Any German living in Germany is a person who lives in Germany.
2) There are people living in Germany who are not German.
The district attorney here applied the “Juristenlogik” (logic of lawyers): Conjectures about the intention of the lawmakers replace the literal wording of a law.
Plus Merkel who just said that if you live in Germany, you are German.
Funny response on https://www.pi-news.net/2017/03/brief-eines-echten-koeters-an-die-deutschen/
Letter from a Real Mutt to the Germans
You Germans, today I heard that one can call you ‘mutt race’ with impunity. I’m appalled! That is a shameless insult – for every upright mutt. Have you ever seen a mutt who allows strangers to take away his laboriously obtained bone? Never. And you, whose savings are melting away like snow in the sun due to the zero interest rate policy […], what are you doing? You watch, as your finance minister basically pays the state debt with several hundred billions of your saved wealth or pays new billions worth of expenses for foreigners.”