Politics and Media Are in Their Own World

Below is a recent op-ed by the well-known German opinion writer Henryk Broder. Many thanks to JLH for translating this piece from Die Welt:

Enraged Citizens

Politics and Media Are in Their Own World

The citizens may not know everything, but they are capable of comparing the mottoes to what they see at their own front doors.

by Henryk Broder
June 16, 2016

Lead photo: Pegida followers in Dresden call for “The Courage for the Truth.” The answers of politicians and the media completely, and obviously, ignore them.

Divers who do more than snorkel on the surface know the danger of coming up again — decompression. Gas bubbles form in the body, interrupting the blood supply.

The diver passes out, respiratory arrest occurs, the circulatory system shuts down. Before it is too late, the diver must be put into a pressure chamber, where the process of resurfacing is replicated slowly, under controlled conditions. Assuming good physical condition and with a little bit of luck, there should be no residual damage.

What is true for the individual diver also applies to whole societies that are going through a radical system change. The citizens of the GDR had only a few months to come up from the depths of their history. No pressure chamber would have been big enough for 17 million people.

The Phenomenon is Neither Exclusively Nor Typically East German

Ostalgie [made-up compound for “nostalgia for the East”] was not an expression of longing for a better yesterday, but an attempt to take leave of that yesterday in a way that was culturally and socially acceptable. You wore an FDJ[1] shirt, drank a Bitterfelder Edel-Pils[ner] and sang along with Frank Schöbel, “Ich geh vom Nordpol zum Südpol zu Fuß,”[2]

The phenomenon is neither exclusively nor typically East German. It also happens in the West, in the Federal Republic — admittedly under different auspices.

People “out there in the country” who have evidently gone astray, and are waiting for the political establishment to come and fetch them back, are overtaxed. They have to manage not only their own lives, but also those of “others.”

The lives of the poor and the needy of the Third World, of the refugees in Greek reception camps, of the single mothers who do not reach out for help to the fathers of their children, but to “society”, which is both guilty of and responsible for everything.

They Should Share Their “Prosperity”

Those “people out there in the country” are repeatedly told that they must share their “prosperity”, and it is no longer fitting “in a globalized world” that “a part of it lives in wealth and peace while other regions are sinking in war and misery.”

So will global justice be achieved when everyone is living in war and misery? Is that why we are so fiercely determined to import the conflicts of the world to Germany?

They Find Out the Joke is on Them

The “ folks out in the country” i.e., “the people” or the “citizens” are not so schooled in dialectics as the authors of these bits of advice, but they do have a gut feeling that helps them to distinguish “right” from “false.” Or at least between “believable” and “fantasized.”

They are capable of comparing what they are told with what happens at their own front doors. And when they hear, for example, that immigration is “an enrichment for our country,” it dawns on them that someone is playing them for fools. They just wonder why.

They don’t like being called nationalists and racists because they won’t be sacrificed for a completely out-of-control immigration and allocation policy.

And they do not appreciate being insulted as a “rabble” by Sigmar Gabriel, who, in one of his rare bright moments, calls for a “social package for the indigenous” and the basis for this call is: We cannot allow “the impression that we would forget our own citizens.”

At such moments, it becomes clear to even the last, clueless, biological German that the “impression” Gabriel is trying to counteract, is not an impression, but an accomplished fact.

The Cosmetic Beautification of Reality

There is hardly a day when reality is not stood on its head, prettied up or whitewashed, as it was in the GDR with the “parade routes” set up for dignitary guests. Or now, when Claus Heber in Heute Journal introduces the outcome of a Swiss referendum on minimum wage with the comment that “something astonishing” had occurred.

“Almost one in four of the allegedly so conservative, frugal Swiss who took part in today’s referendum voted for a utopian idea.” Only later does the reader learn that 77% of the Swiss voted against it.

This kind of cosmetic beautification of reality is also found on a personal level. For instance, when a fire in a Düsseldorf refugee accommodation, which injured dozens, is downgraded by stages. It had been confirmed “that the fire was set ‘from the inside.’”

But still…”the overwhelming majority of the men accommodated in this exhibition hall did not set this fire.” That is good news, anyway, but it suggests the question: How stupid do some journalists think their readers are? Has anyone written anywhere that the overwhelming majority of people who live in Saxony have not taken part in xenophobic protests?

A Dream of “Lebensborn”[3] With an Immigration Background

In the long run, it has not paid to underestimate the “people in the country” just because it takes a while for them to articulate their displeasure. They may not understand energy transition down to the smallest detail, but they wonder at the fact that electricity is getting cheaper on the electricity exchange but more expensive for the users.

They are amazed to hear the minister for agriculture say “in a social market economy, it is not the task of the state to interfere in price policy,” just after the federal cabinet has decided to encourage the sale of electric autos with €4,000 per vehicle — for vehicles costing up to €60,000.

People out in the country wonder what planet Martin Schulz — the ubiquitous president of the European Parliament — is living on. In a speech on “Homeland, Flight and Identity in Times of Globalization,” he maintained that “What the refugees bring us” is “worth more than gold.” Because “It is an unswerving belief in the dream of Europe. A dream that we have lost track of.”

Is there anyone outside of Martin Schulz who is convinced that the refugees set out on the expensive, long and dangerous path to Europe, to save Europe? Possibly Wolfgang Schäuble, who said in an interview: “Isolation is what would destroy us, would make us degenerate into inbreeding.” That really sounded like a dream of Lebensborn, with an immigration twist.

Does Heiko Maas Have Nothing Else to Do?

And when the minister of justice announces he will forbid “sexual advertisement, “ the “people out in the land” do not break out in approving cheers. They wonder: Does the man have nothing else to do? The fact that he does not notice the mockery and the gleeful ridicule directed at him is just further proof of how comfortable he and his ilk have become on the far side of the moon.

In an interview not long ago, Heiko Maas said that there is no fundamental right to internal security: “There is no such fundamental right to internal security in our constitution.” A peek into the constitution would show him that this is not true.

The right to be physically uninjured is one of the fundamental rights, as well as the right to life and the right to personal freedom. All of these together can surely be understood as a basic right to internal security. Seen that way, it is the foremost task of every government to provide for internal security.

Minister Maas, however, would like to “socialize” this job. In another interview, he said that the majority must “be silent no longer” — “We are all called upon: We must slowly pull back the curtain, open the window, show our faces and shout back.”

Maas’s idea is reminiscent of a scene from the 1976 film “Network” — Howard Beale, an aging TV moderator played by Peter Finch, in the middle of his broadcast, exhorts his viewers to go to their windows, open them and shout into the night: “I’m as mad as hell, and I’m not going to take this anymore!” And everywhere in the USA, people open their windows and shout: “I’m as mad as hell, and I’m not going to take this anymore!”

The Remake of the “Uprising of the Respectable”

It is not the first time a member of the administration has called on the silent majority to break its silence and speak out. After a failed arson attack on the Düsseldorf synagogue in early 2002, the federal chancellor at the time, Gerhard Schröder, called for an “Aufstand der Anständigen” — looking the other way, he said, was “no longer allowed.”

After it became known that the arsonists were not, as originally assumed, German rightist radicals, but two “ethnic Arabic” young men — a Moroccan with a German passport and a Palestinian from Jordan — the “Uprising of the Respectable” died aborning.

Now there is supposed to be a remake. Maas does not say what the citizens should shout after they pull back the curtains and show their faces. “Nazis go home!”, “No person is illegal!” or “Germany you crummy piece of s**t!”, as recently heard in a demonstration attended by Claudia Roth, vice president of the Bundestag. It is only clear that the silent majority is expected to bolster the regime.

What the Silent Majority Expects

And actually, the silent majority has enough to do. They have to get up early, take care of the children, drive to work, stand on the assembly line or sit at a desk for eight hours, drive home, go shopping, prepare supper and help the children with their homework.

The silent majority expects that the government will take care of the tasks for which it levies fees from income tax, VAT, tobacco tax, gasoline tax, business tax, liquor tax — that it will take care of internal security and not turn to the citizens for help. That would be like the trash removal service suggesting that citizens bring their trash to the dump to demonstrate their responsibility for the community.

There is only one solution. For the its next closed conference, instead of going to a castle out in the country, the government, should enter a pressure chamber, so they can make the transition from a virtual to the real world.


1.   FDJ = Free German Youth, the only authorized youth organization in the German Democratic Republic
2.   This love song was one of Schöbel’s many hit songs in the GDR.
3.   Program and officially “registered organization” devoted to the maintenance and furthering of the “Aryan” type, extending so far as to spiriting appropriate children away from their families, including in non-German countries and territories under Nazi control, and fostering them with other families, frequently of SS members.

Other photos in order:

1.   Indulging in old memories. A man wearing an FDJ shirt in Berlin
2.   Sigmar Gabriel in Heidenau: “Not one millimeter to the rightist radical rabble.”
3.   The Heute Journal (Today’s Journal) moderator, Claus Kleber.
4.   The automotive summit — Financial start-up aid for electric cars.
5.   Discriminatory advertising — What does pizza have to do with sex?

20 thoughts on “Politics and Media Are in Their Own World

    • When F. Hayek wrote his book “The Road to Serfdom” he dedicated it to “The socialists of all parties”, pointedly, not making any distinction between National Socialists and Social Democrats, because he saw the misery that both of them wanted to impose on us. I think that he was right than and he is still right now. It is not “The Left”, it is “The Socialists of all parties”, even if they are capitalists, technocrats, bureaucrats or whatever have you.

  1. Fascinating article. Perhaps we are looking at the genesis of a truly united Europe, a Europe united by its people in their love of a common ethos, a Europe united by a determination to live in mutual freedom and friendship, a Europe stripped of the ideological manacles slapped upon our wrists by avaricious, totalitarian globalists – a Euroethnic entity in name and reality.

    I do hope so, even though we will find that road lined every metre of the way with illegitimatii and our would be slavemasters – perhaps we should call it the Spartacus movement and then proceed with an absolute determination to succeed where he failed.

    There are, I suspect, enough of us now, and we must join in hand and heart, from the frigid Northern waters to the warm sands and olive groves of the South, and remake our homelands and our continent, Europe.

    If not then I fear another dark age will be upon us, one we may never emerge from.

    S III.

    • Since the Baron likes Daoist stuff:

      明夷 (míng yí), “Darkening of the Light.”


      Brilliance Injured.
      Favorable to be steadfast and upright in hardship.

      Commentary on the Decision:

      Brightness has sunk under the Earth.
      It is Brilliance Injured.

      Inside is grace and brightness.
      Outside is gentle and yielding.
      Confronted by great hardship.
      This was what King Wen experienced.

      Favorable to be steadfast and upright in hardship.
      This is to cover one’s brilliance.

      In the midst of hardship,
      Nonetheless keeping his mind still and his will righteous.
      This was what Ji Zi encountered.

      Commentary on the Symbol:

      Brightness has sunk under the Earth.
      An image of Brilliance Injured.
      In correspondence with this,
      The superior person remains in harmony with the multitude.
      Covering his brilliance, yet his light is still shining.

  2. The world of EUndemocratic EUlite is collaspsing, but these fools are too blind to notice.

  3. The lefties view inequality as a social injustice rather than an inescapable existential fact of human life. Their solution is never to improve the lot of the have-nots but to confiscate the wealth and privileges of the haves, never minding if said wealth & privilege was earned by hard work, sacrifice, prudence and calculated risk.

    • Its called feudalism, it is the natural way of things, Western culture came out of feudalism because of the Black Death, and because the bible was printed in the common language of the people.

      It was a glitch in the normality of slavery.

      Nobody reads the bible anymore, and we have anti-Biotics so the population is increasing rapidly. The education system is almost completely destroyed, our debts are more than our income, so we are all destined to become ‘square deal’ serfs; I owe, I owe its off to work I go….

      • MC, you as a former Brit, and I as a long-standing and current one may understand your pun. Here’s an explanation for those who missed it: in 1964, Unilever relaunched its laundry detergent, “Surf”, with a promise of more powder for one’s money, without other promotional gimmicks, under the slogan “Square Deal Surf”. I’m assuming everyone got the final reference to “Snow White”- was that coincidence deliberate?
        PS Hope you’re not sayng antibiotics are a bad thing; they’ve saved my life.

        • Because Persil adds bright white whiteness I got the idea of Snow white, I was actually trying to think of the OMO jingle which escaped me at the time……

          Anti Biotics are almost the only ‘cure’ in medicine where the main object is ‘treat the symptoms’ (with expensive pharmaceuticals) and not the illness, I have nothing against anti-Biotics themselves, but, in hindsight, they should have been used as a last resort not a first resort (and aid to meat production), because they are very destructive to the body’s own immune systems.

          We also have to look at how modern medicine has caused population explosions in places where the population cannot be sustained; it is no good decreasing peri/post natal death without looking at the whole cradle to grave picture. Instead of vaccinating children with dubious (but very profitable) concoctions, maybe we should be sorting out clean and safe (but unprofitable) water supplies…..

      • The era of effective anti-biotics is coming to an end. In our careless [over-]use of the stuff, we may have created our new “Black Death”. Perhaps genetic measures can save enough specimens for the survival of the herd, but we are separated from that horizon by a massive chasm of cost and a dearth of time . . . a chasm that may very well swallow a large part of the herd. Some tough ethical choices lie ahead: Who will the chosen survivors be? Whose genes will live on? Will we have a policy of eugenics?

        As for debt: The “unborn” of yesterday – when a lot of the debt was contracted – are here today; and they may very well refuse to pay. Expect a lot of defaults or an outright tax revolt.

    • They SAY they want to confiscate from “the rich”, but in reality the haves that they confiscate from are the middle class while the rich are untouched.

      This is less true of the original stuff like Marxism-Leninism where the landlords are chased off only to be replaced by other less competent landlords, and no middle class develops until market economics makes a comeback, but it is certainly true of neo-Marxism where the middle class is destroyed and the landlords are enriched.

  4. In the UK we see something similar over the EU Referendum results. The majority of MPs supported Remain, and now that a Leave was won against long odds, the ruling elites are in no mood to invoke Article 50.

    We also see many MPs refusal to accept the result and many have now tabled a petition to overturn the Referendum result adding exclusion clauses and so in. The campaign as you are well aware was nasty and unpleasant, a female MP with a family was alledgly murdered after deceased Bernard Kenny who died three years ago attempted to save her life.

    Scotland voted 62-38 for Remain probably due to death of Mrs Cox while England and Wales voted 54-46 Leave, NI split almost down the middle. Ethnic minorities voted heavily for Remain and because this fact the result doesn’t stand as it would be racist to leave the EU.

    We are in danger of turning into the next Northern Ireland in which sectarian violence will explode, this time it will be the white English and Welsh will fight the African and Asian colonisers.

    What a sad end to this campaign.


    • The Scottish result shows the pro-brexit majority in England and Wales was rather more than 52/48.

      The Spanish are already saying they’d veto Scotland’s accession, as it would legitimise Catalunya’s (overwhelming) ambition to secede. Plus Scotland would be compelled to join the Euro…

      • The SNP are selling huge lies to the people of Scotland.
        They claim they want an independent and soverereign nation-state but also want to be in the EU, which is almost universally conflated with Europe by the Scottish political and media classes.

        The SNP are also big fans of Globalist/progressive/muktikultist narratives, namely Islam is a religion of peace.
        The SNP have cynically whored after the Muslim vote and Sturgeon’s speech, ‘diversity is strength’ after the (most recent) jihadist attacks in Paris, was an unintentional commentary on the big lies of the progressive movement.

        The SNP, really should change their name to something more apropos, pro-EU Socialists (PEUS).

  5. The problem is not the politician, but the people….
    Although this topic was attached to the This is the topic of the previous post, but it’s just as relevant to this one. Our leaders are unable to educate us/persuade us/intimidate us to the degree that is necessary to sustain their agenda. Put simply, the world view they want us to adopt is increasingly at odds with our reality.

  6. Correction:

    The problem is not the politician, but the people….
    Although this topic was attached to the previous post, it’s just as relevant to this one. Our leaders are unable to educate us/persuade us/intimidate us to the degree that is necessary to sustain their agenda. Put simply, the world view they want us to adopt is increasingly at odds with our reality.

    Apologies folks, an accidental send…

Comments are closed.