Ali Sina: The Illusion of Reforming Islam

From Fjordman: Here is an essay about the impossibility of reforming Islam. It was written by Ali Sina, the Iranian ex-Muslim who has written the book Understanding Muhammad, which I have reviewed before at Jihad Watch:

The Illusion of Reforming Islam

The so called reformers of Islam are misguided at best and deceptive at worst. Their efforts should not be welcomed. Whatever their intention, whether genuine or malicious, they are pulling wool over the eyes of non-Muslims and as the result giving legitimacy to a very evil and dangerous creed.

Only truth can set us free. By sugarcoating Islam you cannot change its nature. You can purify filthy water and drink it. You can even purify urine into drinking water. But can you purify gasoline enough to make it drinkable? The essence of Islam is evil. It is not a contaminated good faith. You cannot reform it enough to make it a humane faith. Can you reform Nazism? This whole notion is misguided and absurd.

– – – – – – – –

What is the point of reforming a religion founded by a mentally deranged man who committed so much evil on Earth, who lied, decieved, rapied, tortured, raided, looted, massacred and committed the most despicable crimes? Why keep his cult alive and his memory honored? That man deseves scorn, not recognition?

Reforming Islam is impossible. It is either a dilution or a ruse. Jiahd is based on two pillars, war and deception. I don’t want anyone to be fooled by the soothing promises of Muslim reformers. Moderate Islam does not exist. It’s a myth.

I prefer jihadi Muslims to these “Muslims against Sharia,” fellows. With the jihadis I know my enemy. I do not trust Muslims who are against Sharia. I do not understand them. What they say does not add up. I don’t know what they are up to. I do not trust people who say, I am a follower of Muhammad, but I do not follow Muhammad. There is something fishy, something dishonest and hypocritical about their claim.

11 thoughts on “Ali Sina: The Illusion of Reforming Islam

  1. I note from BBC tv news this morning that the Egyptians have set up a website to help ‘troubled’ Muslims worldwide – the aim being to deflect them away from radicalism.

  2. An honest assessment is Islam’s greatest fear.No one could defend the model of the “perfect” man, the pedophile “prophet” Mohammad, and not be in the camp of Bin Laden and the Taliban, since they are his truest adherents.

    The soft-pedalling “moderates” are either downplaying the true intolerant and misogynistic and terroristic nature of their imperialistic “religion” and its dismal, tyrannical dogmas… in order to sucker the infidels into slow submission to their infiltration… or they are as ignorant of Islam, beyond the sugar-coated superficiliaties, as most infidel dogs (like George W. Bush and Mrs. Blair, et al) claim to be.

    I salute Ali Sina for his open challenge to the Mohammedans to be honest …or be quiet.

    The more they speak out in defense of “the Religion of Peace”… in the naked face of its brutality and expansionistic violence… the more studiously “ignorant” or shamelessly deceptive disinformation artists they show themselves to be.

  3. The way I see it, there is no differenc between moderate muslims and jihadists. The former is just using taqyyia and kitman while the latter is more frank about their intentions. At the end of the day, they both work for the same goal, to submit all humans on earth to allah, to spread their infection to the whole body. The jihadist is a murderer, plain and simple while the moderate is more devious and clever using stealth to infiltrate the infidel but in the end, they both want the destruction of the dar al-harb so that they can assimilate the kufr into their global ummah.

  4. The essence of Islam is evil. It is not a contaminated good faith.

    The irresitable Liberal tendency to sugarcoat Islam derives from the same Politically Correct obsession with how it is possible to pick up a turd by its clean end.

    Like a turd, Islam has no clean end. Sampled at any point, it is still the same old crap. It is rotten to the core and nothing exemplifies this better than one simple fact:


    One would think that the profound stagnation of all Muslim majority countries would trumpet this fact to all within hearing distance.

    Islam’s endemic corruption, abject gender apartheid, mutilations and amputations, endless prohibitions and persistent abuse of children all bespeak an intensely brittle culture that has long ago worn out its welcome upon civilization’s stage.

    More than anything, within Islam, faith is merely window dressing for a far deeper fanaticism that is required in order to swallow the Qu’ranic camel whole whilst still remaining able to choke oneself purple upon the Western gnats of gender equality and social drinking.

  5. I wonder why to use the term islam.
    It is just one grotesque-evil biography of a man. Too funny – once disconnected from real life.

    Like selling diseases in a pharmacy.

  6. A line from Ali Sina: “Only truth can set us free.”

    A lie from Ali Sina: “the ‘moderates’ also confess of being hypocites. They will tell you they believe in Islam but they are not good Muslims.”

    Ali Sina has the right to view Islam any way he wants to. However, supporting his arguments by making stuff up puts him in the same category of lying scumbags as CAIR who claim that there Islam has nothing to do with terrorism.

  7. It is esp. difficult to become a good muslimah. If you get a degree at the university, you contradict islam and you are an apostate.

    Start measuring muslims by an educated muslimah, not by Mo. It will start to be funny and interesting. They are (muslims) obviously unable to follow islamic dogmas, being more stupid than that muslimah. That clearly contradicts the teachings of islam too.

    Also poor muslims contradict islam:
    Mo said it is a sign of disbelief to be poor. (He was apparently “rich”.)

  8. There are 1 billon muslim, the best way is to educate the muslim about islam, teach them at the low
    level,high level most of the muslim. could not understand islam.The intellectual muslim who can read and understand the koran refuse to acknowledge and accept that the koran is not a religious book by allah, but an instrument of war,use by the messenger…
    Every muslim has a good eye sight and a bright way of life prepare for them, but muslim prefered to close their eyes and refuse to see
    where they are going…

Comments are closed.