The Dying Fall

Sixth in an occasional series on the poetry of Louis MacNeice
Anti-aircraft battery in Southwark Park, London, 1939

One of Louis MacNeice’s most powerful and enduring works is “Autumn Journal”, a long poem of twenty-four sections. It was written in the fall of 1939 during the “Phony War”, the period after Britain and France declared war against Germany, but before the serious fighting began.

Hyde Park, London, 1939Gloom and foreboding were the order of the day in Britain. Everyone knew that terrible events were coming, but not just yet. While their governments prepared for war, people in Britain went about their normal affairs. The autumn of 1939 was the last time of normalcy that Western Europe would know.

Memories of the Great War were only two decades old, and the quality of Hitler’s war machine was well known, so a huge cataclysm was expected. A hint of this context is contained in the third and fourth lines of the excerpt below: the “raw clay trenches” that disfigured parkland throughout London were hastily excavated bomb shelters for the expected air raids, and anti-aircraft batteries could be seen throughout London. The Spanish Civil War, just recently ended, had demonstrated the effectiveness of the Luftwaffe, and Britain anticipated a horrific air war.

But in this excerpt MacNeice, who lectured in Greek at the University of London, takes a detour to the distant past, looking at the ancient world through the fatalistic lens of 1939.

From “Autumn Journal” (Part IX)
By Louis MacNeice

October comes with rain whipping around the ankles
     In waves of white at night
And filling the raw clay trenches (the parks of London
     Are a nasty sight).
In a week I return to work, lecturing, coaching,
     As impresario of the Ancient Greeks
Who wore the chiton and lived on fish and olives
     And talked philosophy or smut in cliques;
Who believed in youth and did not gloze the unpleasant
     Consequences of age;
What is life, one said, or what is pleasant
     Once you have turned the page
Of love? The days grow worse, the dice are loaded
     Against the living man who pays in tears for breath;
Never to be born was the best, call no man happy
     This side death.
Conscious — long before Engels — of necessity
     And therein free
They plotted out their life with truism and humour
     Between the jealous heaven and the callous sea.
And Pindar sang the garland of wild olive
     And Alcibiades lived from hand to mouth
Double-crossing Athens, Persia, Sparta,
     And many died in the city of plague, and many of drouth
In Sicilian quarries, and many by the spear and arrow
     And many more who told their lies too late
Caught in the eternal factions and reactions
     Of the city-state.
And free speech shivered on the pikes of Macedonia
     And later on the swords of Rome
And Athens became a mere university city
     And the goddess born of the foam
Became the kept hetæra, heroine of Menander,
     And the philosopher narrowed his focus, confined
His efforts to putting his own soul in order
     And keeping a quiet mind.
And for a thousand years they went on talking,
     Making such apt remarks,
A race no longer of heroes but of professors
     And crooked business men and secretaries and clerks,
Who turned out dapper little elegiac verses
     On the ironies of fate, the transience of all
Affections, carefully shunning an over-statement
     But working the dying fall.
The Glory that was Greece: put it in a syllabus, grade it
     Page by page
To train the mind or even to point a moral
     For the present age:
Models of logic and lucidity, dignity, sanity,
     The golden mean between opposing ills
Though there were exceptions of course but
                    only exceptions
     The bloody Bacchanals on the Thracian hills.
So the humanist in his room with Jacobean panels
     Chewing his pipe and looking on a lazy quad
Chops the Ancient World to turn a sermon
     To the greater glory of God.
But I can do nothing so useful or so simple;
     These dead are dead
And when I should remember the paragons of Hellas
     I think instead
Of the crooks, the adventurers, the opportunists,
     The careless athletes and the fancy boys,
The hair-splitters, the pedants, the hard-boiled sceptics
     And the Agora and the noise
Of the demagogues and the quacks; and the women pouring
     Libations over graves
And the trimmers at Delphi and the dummies at Sparta
                    and lastly
     I think of the slaves.
And how one can imagine oneself among them
     I do not know;
It was all so unimaginably different
     And all so long ago.

Notice the gratuitous appearance of Engels midway through this excerpt. It was virtually impossible for any British literary work of the 1930s to avoid some mention of Socialism; it was the air of the times, and everybody breathed it.

But the poet has carefully avoided “presentism” in his depiction of the Greeks. In evoking antiquity, he has brought it to our understanding while at the same time demonstrating its inescapable otherness.

And so it is with 1939. Though it is scarcely two generations back, and many people now alive remember it still…

It was all so unimaginably different, and all so long ago.

4 thoughts on “The Dying Fall

  1. It was all so unimaginably different, and all so long ago.

    That perfectly reinforces the implications of the earlier lines:

    And for a thousand years they went on talking,
    Making such apt remarks,
    A race no longer of heroes but of professors
    And crooked business men and secretaries and clerks,
    Who turned out dapper little elegiac verses
    On the ironies of fate, the transience of all…

    On one hand we understand that MacNeice is using the ancients as metaphor to reference his fellow English, and yet “a thousand years” and “a race no longer of heroes” seems also to not-too-subtly reference the Nazi regime. Just as unmistakably “the ironies of fate, the transience of all” leaves us to believe he considered the projection of a thousand-year reign of supermen somewhat overly optimistic.

    As full of gloom and foreboding as this poem is, it is precisely because nothing of this world is forever that in the face of impending disaster there remains reason for hope. Of course, looking back on that time from our present perspective, we tend to see as a lesson in hope what those then living could only pray would be true.

  2. An interesting time: as your man Hap Arnold said, in July 1940 the RAF took off to save everything, by September they had saved it. Had Britain lost the Battle of Britain uItimately wastern Europe would have been swamped by Russia (discuss). That we were in a position to fight the BoB was due to to some prescience: stubborn military leaders who anticipated the Luftwaffe threat and insisted the we needed modern monoplane fighters, Churchill and his supporters who refused Hitler’s repeated efforts to get Britain to leave Nazi Germanyh to it, scientists who developed radar and the distributed command and control system. Churchill’s oratory, the Spitfire as a symbol of resistance (didn’t hurt that it could spank the Bf 109, too) and the Hawker Hurricane: the Spit’s much underestimated partner. Slower, less elegant and iconic that the Spitfire, but a better gun platform, it formed the bulk of Fighter Command’s forces in 1940 and took 2/3 of the BoB kills. That we had a fighter force at all was due to the boss of Hawker Aviation underwriting the building of 600 Hurricanes while the government debated. Had we not had those Hurris, the Luftwaffe would have been able to steamroller a small fighter command and clear the way for a seaborne invasion of Britain: no base for D-day and the liberation of Europe.

    In 1939 a lot of good people on this island were anticipating what the Luftwaffe would do with great acccuracy and preparing to counter it. Poets wrote, and maybe reflected what went on in their own circles. Meanwhile great engineers were creating the Rolls Royce Merlin, the elliptical Spitfire wing, making invisible waves detect distant bombers, heads of corporations were writing big cheques to make sure that ‘the few’ had planes to climb into come the Blitz and great tacticians were preparing the air defence system on which the Luftwaffe would ultimately throw away many machines and brave men. My cat is now giving me that ‘shut up’ look, so I will.

  3. I can’t match the two previous excellent comments. I’ll only say that I feel a sense of foreboding, mixed with impatience. For the past few months it’s as if I’ve just been going through the motions of my life while waiting for the other shoe to drop.

    Not sure what I’m supposed to do when it does drop.

  4. Completely and utterly WRONG. The poem was written during the autumn of 1938 during the period of the Munich crisis, ONE WHOLE YEAR before the outbreak of WWII. Talk about missing the point…

Comments are closed.