Haim Dynovisz is a French-speaking rabbi who now lives in Israel. He recorded the following video back in January, a few days after the Charlie Hebdo massacre in Paris. In it he advises the people of the West, especially Western Jews, to stop being lulled to sleep by the lies of their political leaders. He maintains that the nature of Islam and Muslims is radically misunderstood in the West, whose leaders believe that Muslims think and reason the same way they do.
Rabbi Dynovisz has a dire message for the rabbis and Jewish communities of France: “Leave before it’s too late.”
Many thanks to Oz-Rita for the translation, and to Vlad Tepes for the subtitling:
The above clip is a lengthy excerpt from the original video. A shorter excerpt will be available later.
Transcript (times are from the original longer video):
00:00 | Today is Thursday | |
00:04 | 24 (Tevet)? and | |
00:08 | 15 January 2015 | |
00:12 | ||
09:22 | France continues. | |
09:26 | France who is porte-parole, | |
09:30 | (aware or not ) for Europe | |
09:34 | and more widely of the West or for a | |
09:38 | certain part of the West. France continues to absolutely deny | |
09:42 | the evidence and wants to re-name things | |
09:46 | and not give them their real names. | |
09:50 | Those who run their cars into people are “mental”, | |
09:54 | and look at how France, | |
09:58 | the word is perhaps strong, abjectly | |
10:02 | in the sense that they hold hostage | |
10:06 | inside a net of lies, 50 million, | |
10:10 | 60 million people in doing everything | |
10:14 | so that they don’t wake up, | |
10:18 | how they disarm them in the face of | |
10:22 | what is happening. | |
10:27 | How France holds her own population | |
10:31 | hostage by this refusal | |
10:35 | to call things by their names. Let’s take one example, | |
10:39 | so clear and so enormous that | |
10:43 | no-one sees it any longer. The manner | |
10:47 | in which those who massacred the journalists | |
10:51 | of Charlie Hebdo are described. | |
10:55 | The word was: we will not allow | |
10:59 | an attack on the supreme value | |
11:03 | of France: Freedom of speech | |
11:07 | these wicked persons have attacked freedom | |
11:11 | of speech, which is the soul, the essence, | |
11:15 | the flag of France. Indeed France, | |
11:19 | as one knows, shines by its freedom of speech | |
11:23 | of a certain kind, but that’s not the subject, | |
11:27 | however superficially it’s true. So the meme: | |
11:31 | We will not permit an attack our freedom | |
11:35 | of speech. Look how | |
11:39 | the intellectual horror is not even ashamed any longer | |
11:43 | to show itself and to speak. | |
11:47 | Yes this was a terror attack against the freedom of | |
11:51 | speech. Only the “freedom of speech”? | |
11:55 | French people, they lie to you, | |
11:59 | and you are lied to with such malice, | |
12:03 | with such chutzpa that I don’t understand how you did not take to the streets | |
12:07 | by the millions | |
12:11 | to revolt against the lies that they spew into your faces. | |
12:15 | Against freedom of speech only? | |
12:19 | Do you understand what I am trying to say? | |
12:23 | Against freedom of speech. But that’s nothing; | |
12:27 | in reality they lie to you and hide the real problem. | |
12:31 | It is not against freedom of speech, | |
12:35 | the problem. It’s against the freedom to exist. | |
12:39 | It is your existence itself which is attacked. | |
12:43 | Not only your right to express yourselves. | |
12:47 | By choosing to present these terrorists | |
12:51 | as those who attack freedom of speech, the | |
12:55 | French leaders have deliberately | |
12:59 | chosen to lie, to minimise to the extremity | |
13:03 | of the real problem. Because one can well survive without | |
13:07 | expressing oneself. But here it’s much more serious. | |
13:11 | What is targetted | |
13:15 | is simply the right to exist. | |
13:19 | The right of the West | |
13:23 | the right of the Westerner, the right of the Christian | |
13:27 | or the secular to exist. | |
13:31 | This is what it is about, and they don’t want to tell you the truth. | |
13:35 | Let’s go a little further. | |
13:39 | Of course the immediate official reaction | |
13:43 | was: we must not | |
13:47 | confuse the issue; we must not sink into | |
13:51 | confusion and fanaticism; they are not all like this; the great majority | |
13:55 | are not like that. But do you | |
13:59 | understand the criminal significance | |
14:03 | of this affirmation, which in itself is correct, | |
14:07 | which does not diminish in any way | |
14:11 | its criminal dimension? Why criminal? | |
14:15 | But of course, and we all agree, and I tell you | |
14:19 | most sincerely, we are all agreed | |
14:23 | that the majority of Muslims have nothing | |
14:27 | to do with the monsters who act in their name. | |
14:31 | But it’s obvious, it’s more than evident | |
14:36 | one has to be a total idiot to feel the need to say it, | |
14:40 | because one has to be fully (sorry about the rude word) | |
14:44 | cretinous and worse to imagine that they are all | |
14:48 | like that. But why do I say that it’s criminal | |
14:52 | to say it? Because, French people, once more | |
14:56 | they put you to sleep, they prevent you from waking up. | |
15:00 | They do not tell you the truth. | |
15:04 | They do not remind you of obvious historical facts which an 8-year-old | |
15:08 | should know about and understand. | |
15:12 | What do I mean? | |
15:16 | I mean that evidently the great majority has nothing to do with | |
15:20 | these terrorists. But the problem, my friends, is that history | |
15:24 | was never made – neither good nor | |
15:28 | bad – with or thanks to the majority. | |
15:32 | It was never the majority who | |
15:36 | made history. The majority did not create the world and | |
15:40 | the majority has never destroyed the world, the majority has never changed the world, | |
15:44 | and the majority has never prevented the world from changing. | |
15:48 | It’s not the majority who brought us freedom; | |
15:52 | it’s never the majority who takes away freedom; | |
15:56 | it’s never the majority who kills, who massacres or who commits genocide. | |
16:00 | Never! It’s always the minority. | |
16:04 | It’s only the minority who makes history, in good as in evil, | |
16:08 | and unfortunately mostly in evil. | |
16:12 | It was always the majority who made history. | |
16:16 | Even as a Jew, a child of parents who escaped the Holocaust, | |
16:20 | I affirm that it was not the majority of Germans | |
16:24 | who were Nazis, but it was the majority | |
16:28 | of Germans who did not prevent the Nazis | |
16:32 | from ruling Germany. | |
16:36 | It’s the minority who makes history. | |
16:40 | It’s not the majority. | |
16:44 | What does a minority need? A cowardly and silent majority, | |
16:48 | a majority that does not dare | |
16:52 | to expose itself to danger and face a minority | |
16:56 | that is mad, vicious and dangerous. | |
17:00 | And when the minority faces a majority | |
17:04 | that’s silent, lazy and cowardly, | |
17:08 | the minority drags along the majority | |
17:12 | and forces it to accept what the minority wants. | |
17:16 | That was the case in Germany. | |
17:20 | It was like this in history; all dictatorships used | |
17:24 | a cowardly and silent majority to impose their will. | |
17:28 | The dictatorship of the minority. | |
17:32 | It is absolutely evident, | |
17:36 | even more evident | |
17:41 | than what we are saying, | |
17:45 | when we affirm that the majority of Muslims have nothing | |
17:49 | to do with terrorism. It’s absolute evidence. | |
17:53 | But equally absolute evidence is | |
17:57 | to say that this majority does not | |
18:01 | oppose, and will never oppose the | |
18:05 | minority that | |
18:09 | if it manages to impose itself, | |
18:13 | will take with them without any difficulty | |
18:17 | the majority, if only by their silence. | |
18:21 | And one of the millions of proofs | |
18:25 | until today, including | |
18:29 | the march which gathered 1 or 2 or 3 | |
18:33 | million people some days ago. | |
18:37 | Up to now have you seen the Muslim majority | |
18:41 | protest in all the countries of the world | |
18:45 | by the million, by the billion, | |
18:49 | because they are hundreds of millions, | |
18:53 | the Muslim majority protest, even if only | |
18:57 | to shout their indignation in the face of | |
19:01 | what is happening in Syria or in Iraq? | |
19:05 | Have you seen this majority protest, speak up | |
19:09 | by hundreds of millions in the street: “that’s not Islam”? | |
19:13 | No. And even in this march | |
19:17 | which took place a few days ago, it was not a protest, | |
19:21 | thanks to the initiative of | |
19:25 | the Muslim population. It’s the French government. | |
19:29 | In a way it’s France | |
19:33 | that protested. It’s not Islam. | |
19:37 | Even if there were among them probably | |
19:41 | some thousands of Muslims, but it was as citizens of France, | |
19:45 | not as representatives of Islam. | |
19:49 | So we still wait for this protest march, | |
19:53 | which should attract several thousand millions of Muslim | |
19:57 | in the world. But where are you? Protest! Get into the streets! | |
20:01 | Raise up the honour of Allah of Mohammed your prophet, | |
20:05 | whom we respect sincerely; we have nothing | |
20:09 | against Allah, nor Mohammed nor | |
20:13 | the Koran. Nothing. | |
20:17 | We have nothing against you. But where are you? | |
20:21 | Why don’t you protest? Why | |
20:25 | don’t you distance yourselves, officially, openly | |
20:29 | from the monsters who use your god, your prophet | |
20:33 | and your Koran to smear the image | |
20:37 | of Muslims all over the entire world. Why don’t you do something? | |
20:41 | Until there is proof to the contrary, I have the answer: | |
20:45 | because you are not different from the others. | |
20:49 | You are just like all the others, in the whole world; you are | |
20:53 | the silent majority who allow | |
20:57 | and will allow the mad minority | |
21:01 | to perhaps take power one day, | |
21:05 | and to massacre down to the very last Frenchman in France, | |
21:09 | the last non-Muslim European in Europe, | |
21:13 | and who knows how far this will go? And in a certain way, | |
21:17 | knowingly or not, you prepare the extinction | |
21:21 | of Europe. Once more, let’s return | |
21:25 | to that so-called “evidence” | |
21:29 | proclaimed highly by all the world’s governments | |
21:33 | and recently by France: No conflation! But who talks about “amalgame” | |
21:38 | who apart from a raging mad racist | |
21:42 | would recognise themselves | |
21:46 | in an accusation “they are ALL like this”. Obviously | |
21:50 | they are not ALL like this. I, who today suffer | |
21:54 | so much as a Jew because of Islam, | |
21:58 | I make no conflation, and I affirm loud and clear | |
22:02 | that they are not all like this and that the majority | |
22:06 | is not like this. But what has that to do with the historical reality! | |
22:10 | It’s not the majority who will commit genocide | |
22:14 | against the world; it’s the minority surfing on a majority | |
22:18 | that’s cowardly, lazy and silent. | |
22:22 | Just like all majorities. | |
22:26 | So in the end: they lie, they lie, they lie | |
22:30 | and they continue to lie. Whatever you do, French people, don’t wake up. | |
22:34 | Remain asleep. Put your trust | |
22:38 | in the Republic which, of course, will take care of your future, | |
22:42 | and will do everything to save you from extinction. Continue to trust | |
22:46 | all those liars who lie to you and who don’t call things | |
22:50 | by their names. Those who mow you down | |
22:54 | with their cars are not mentally retarded. | |
22:58 | Those who assassinated journalists | |
23:02 | at Charlie Hebdo are not only | |
23:06 | extremists who hate freedom of expression, | |
23:10 | and the minority who do not represent | |
23:14 | the majority does not care not to belong | |
23:18 | to the majority because anyway | |
23:22 | they don’t need the majority to get into power; | |
23:26 | they only need to be allowed to take power. | |
23:30 | And the majority, knowingly or not, does everything | |
23:34 | to let them take power. | |
23:38 | Let’s go a little further. Let’s analyse these | |
23:42 | events. This famous march | |
23:46 | which brought together in France and Paris | |
23:50 | more than 1 million protesters, and in France even more, | |
23:54 | and of course everyone is moved. | |
23:58 | The Republic watches over us, we have no | |
24:02 | worries, that’s it, | |
24:06 | things are under control. Firstly, | |
24:10 | before analysing what happened, just a little history. | |
24:14 | Ah, suddenly France seems to wake up, | |
24:18 | but after decades | |
24:22 | during which France and Europe | |
24:26 | planted the seeds of | |
24:30 | lies in an earth of hypocrisy. | |
24:34 | Did you expect anything other | |
24:39 | than a harvest of death and terrorism? | |
24:43 | What am I saying: | |
24:47 | For decades | |
24:51 | Europe has knelt before | |
24:55 | Islam. Not Islam as “religion”, | |
24:59 | but Islam as economic, political force, | |
25:03 | whatever. | |
25:07 | It’s already been decades that France | |
25:11 | that Europe, through self-interest of course, | |
25:15 | not for making them happy nor out of respect, | |
25:19 | but it has been decades that Europe has been playing the card | |
25:23 | of Islam, the Arab and the Muslim card. | |
25:27 | Petrol etc. | |
25:31 | For decades Europe | |
25:35 | has hoped that showing its face | |
25:39 | smiling and understanding, | |
25:43 | always on the side of | |
25:47 | those who serve the interests | |
25:51 | of France or Europe. It’s been decades | |
25:55 | that Europe has imagined earning | |
25:59 | the kindness, | |
26:03 | the respect of that world there, | |
26:07 | and for decades Europe and France have been | |
26:11 | making the same mistake: it’s not | |
26:15 | by kneeling down before them | |
26:19 | that you will gain respect and consideration. | |
26:23 | Even if it is clear that | |
26:27 | these genuflections are simply self-interest. | |
26:31 | That’s perhaps even worse, because in their eyes, | |
26:35 | if one kneels down before them | |
26:39 | and smiles and makes whoopee and pirouettes, | |
26:43 | even if it serves | |
26:47 | your self-interest, but everything you gain | |
26:51 | in exchange is totally disreputable, | |
26:55 | held in total contempt. Because there is one thing | |
26:59 | you don’t want to understand, that is that the West, including Israel, | |
27:03 | because unfortunately we here in Israel are strongly influenced | |
27:07 | by Western thought or malady – you want to | |
27:11 | absolutely put into your head | |
27:15 | that their world functions like yours, | |
27:19 | that the Muslim mind resembles the mind | |
27:23 | of the Christian. That Arabs react | |
27:27 | and function like Westerners. | |
27:31 | But what you have refused to understand for decades, | |
27:35 | with them, they function | |
27:39 | exactly inversely. | |
27:43 | Try to understand this crazy mechanism of “I do one thing and they understand the complete opposite”. | |
27:47 | Among us, if I do something one understands what I do. When I say | |
27:51 | “one” everyone hears “one”, when I say “white” everyone understands “white” How come | |
27:55 | when I say “one” they hear “two or zero” when I say “white” they hear “black” | |
27:59 | or “green” or “blue”? How is it possible? | |
28:03 | The answer is simple: you are so full of pride, | |
28:07 | to believe that you know all, and to | |
28:11 | dump your kind of thinking onto others, that you fail to realise | |
28:16 | that you have bought the rope | |
28:20 | by which you are about to hang yourself. These people | |
28:24 | don’t think like you. | |
28:28 | When you try to smile at them, to show | |
28:32 | that you are on their side, that you kneel down in front of them, that | |
28:36 | you have empathy, that you do everything to serve their interests, | |
28:40 | all this with them | |
28:44 | is understood in one word: | |
28:48 | weakness, cowardice, | |
28:52 | lack of dignity. They don’t understand | |
28:56 | things the way you think they do. | |
29:00 | “If we are on your side, be on our side.” | |
29:04 | “If we are with you out of self-interest, at least be with us | |
29:08 | out of self-interest. | |
29:12 | This is a Western, a Christian discourse, it doesn’t work. | |
29:16 | They don’t understand this. | |
29:20 | They respect only strength, only courage, only grandeur, | |
29:24 | only resolution. That civilisation | |
29:28 | understands only the language of the strong. | |
29:32 | Not the one of love, of kindness, | |
29:36 | of compassion, of pity, not even that of self-interest. | |
29:40 | They only respect the strong. | |
29:44 | And when they see that the West, especially the French, | |
29:48 | start to make pirouettes and summersaults | |
29:52 | and all forms of prostration, | |
29:56 | even if they know that this is only | |
30:00 | superficial, because | |
30:04 | in the end everyone acts in their own interest, | |
30:08 | but the difference is that the real Muslim | |
30:12 | even in his self-interest he does not prostrate himself, he does not | |
30:16 | lower his head, he does not make pirouettes | |
30:20 | even in his own interest because Islam | |
30:24 | venerates only the strong | |
30:28 | and force, and he respects only the one who knows how to get respect. | |
30:32 | so, little French, how are you seen? | |
30:36 | what do you look like? You look | |
30:40 | cowardly, weak; you have no more dignity | |
30:44 | in their eyes. And the more you try | |
30:48 | to serve their interests, the more you try to be on their side, | |
30:52 | the more compassion and pity you have, the more they | |
30:56 | spit in your face, the more they hate you, the more they will humiliate you | |
31:00 | and the more you will be an object of contempt | |
31:04 | in their eyes, because above all | |
31:08 | they hate those without self respect, | |
31:12 | they hate those who’ve lost their dignity, | |
31:16 | they hate those who will sell | |
31:20 | themselves to serve the interests, | |
31:24 | those who have no more value than a can of petrol. | |
31:28 | And you still don’t get it, it is you, | |
31:32 | you, you, the different French governments who brought | |
31:37 | death on your people. It’s you | |
31:41 | who are preparing everything which has yet to happen, | |
31:45 | because you have not understood, you the Europeans, | |
31:49 | that you have sold your dignity for decades, | |
31:53 | and that is why they will never ever | |
31:57 | forgive you, because they will never | |
32:01 | make peace nor negotiate with | |
32:05 | a civilisation that has sold its dignity. | |
32:09 | And this you will understand, but too late. | |
32:13 | Instead of having learned it softly, calmly | |
32:17 | in the schools, you will learn it | |
32:21 | in the streets. Instead of | |
32:25 | learning it in comfort, you will learn it under terror, | |
32:29 | and that’s irreversible, because | |
32:33 | your disease is already in the stage of death throes, | |
32:37 | and you will be unable to escape. That’s probably why | |
32:41 | the leaders lie to their people, because they know that the patient | |
32:45 | is incurable, so they might as well continue to make them believe that they are madmen | |
32:49 | driving the cars, might as well continue to make them believe | |
32:53 | that only freedom of speech is in danger. | |
32:57 | Might as well keep making them believe | |
33:01 | they are better off and that we will come out of it. | |
33:05 | Continue to put your people to sleep, | |
33:09 | France, continue to sleep, never mind; | |
33:13 | perhaps it’s better to die while asleep than awake. | |
33:17 | Perhaps it hurts less, one is less aware of it. | |
33:21 | I’d like to address another important fact: | |
33:25 | this famous march, yes | |
33:29 | grand march, I’m saying this sincerely, | |
33:33 | but always the same window, | |
33:37 | the same unacceptable window | |
33:41 | which the majority did not analyse. | |
33:45 | I’m not the only one who has seen this. | |
33:49 | I was still in the US when in my inbox | |
33:53 | several emails asked me to intervene, | |
33:57 | to say something, asking me if one should go to this march or not. | |
34:01 | As I have explained, technically and more deeply, | |
34:05 | I did not want to take a position spontaneously, | |
34:09 | but to those who asked me if they should go | |
34:13 | I immediately said no, don’t go. | |
34:17 | Nobody asked me why; those who asked me know me too well, | |
34:21 | and understood my answer well and fast. | |
34:25 | Why? Because at a demonstration where the leader | |
34:29 | of the State of Israel accepts | |
34:33 | finding himself a few meters | |
34:37 | from the representative of the Palestinian Authority – | |
34:41 | I think the message is so | |
34:46 | enormous, the message, | |
34:50 | the terrible message is so enormous, | |
34:54 | that one needs to be of extreme bad faith, | |
34:58 | unimaginable, | |
35:02 | a total refusal to interpret | |
35:06 | what this kind of situation | |
35:10 | could signify, | |
35:14 | a total refusal of interpretation | |
35:18 | to still participate in this kind of demonstration; I explain: | |
35:22 | What is Abbas doing over there? | |
35:26 | What is he doing over there, | |
35:30 | but what is the connection? | |
35:34 | What is the connection. It’s Europe that is in danger today – | |
35:38 | what is the connection? He is not even yet | |
35:42 | an official Leader of State; what is he doing there? | |
35:46 | Later we will try to understand what Benjamin Netanyahu | |
35:50 | did there. But what is Abbas doing there? | |
35:54 | My friends, the message is so cruel | |
35:58 | and so horrid that, frankly, | |
36:02 | I feel ill. | |
36:06 | I nearly fell. | |
36:10 | I feel sick. | |
36:14 | I can hardly say it, I kick my health | |
36:18 | saying it, so much I don’t want to say it, it’s a danger for my health. | |
36:22 | So much, I swear I feel ill saying it. | |
36:26 | What message? But the message is simple. | |
36:30 | Here, at home, in France, | |
36:34 | here in Europe, it is terrorism | |
36:38 | understood, it is only terrorism against freedom of speech, | |
36:42 | of course. Here it’s terrorism | |
36:46 | but against the Jews in Israel, they are not terrorists, | |
36:50 | they are liberators, | |
36:54 | and so that there is no doubt, | |
36:58 | here at home in Israel it’s the Muslims, over there it’s | |
37:02 | the Muslims. Here at home it’s the Muslims over there it’s the Muslims | |
37:06 | referring themselves openly to the Koran | |
37:10 | and to the religion | |
37:14 | of Islam, and at your home, in France it’s | |
37:18 | terrorists who openly refer themselves to the Koran and their religion of Islam. | |
37:22 | So, the bridge… perhaps | |
37:26 | the analogy is a (..?…) If here in Israel | |
37:30 | they are real terrorists, nasty, not nice, so perhaps | |
37:34 | at your place in France also… ahh, no no no no no | |
37:38 | no no no !! Here (France) these are nasty terrorists | |
37:42 | at your place, in Israel, they are liberators, | |
37:46 | even if they do the same thing, even if they speak to | |
37:50 | the same god, invoke the same prophet, | |
37:54 | study the same work: in Israel they are | |
37:58 | liberators; they have the right, the duty to do it, | |
38:02 | and let them continue to do it, | |
38:06 | and to show it to the whole world we can all kick the bucket. | |
38:10 | The world couldn’t care less, they only demonstrate when it happens over there | |
38:14 | in France; one asks Abbas to come urgently, | |
38:18 | even though he has nothing to do over there, | |
38:22 | one asks him to come so that the message remains strong | |
38:26 | “those who kill the Jews in Israel are liberators, not terrorists.” | |
38:30 | My friends, | |
38:34 | it is at the moment of this demonstration (you hear?), | |
38:38 | record it, keep it, because it will come out | |
38:43 | in the near future: The day Abbas | |
38:47 | participated in this demonstration, the French government | |
38:51 | signed by their own hand that the terrorist attacks will continue. | |
38:55 | Yes, you said that | |
38:59 | those who run us down with their cars are liberators; | |
39:03 | in France they are the mentally ill. | |
39:07 | We had the “liberators”; you had your “mentally ill” who | |
39:11 | run down your people. You said that | |
39:15 | the Palestinians had a duty to IMPOSE their peace | |
39:19 | according to their conditions, you | |
39:23 | had Charlie Hebdo, you asked Abbas | |
39:27 | to demonstrate with you to make the entire world understand, | |
39:31 | especially the Jews, that “you just snuff it in Israel”, | |
39:35 | because in Israel they are not terrorists but liberators. | |
39:39 | I prefer to say nothing regarding the continuation of events in France | |
39:43 | You continue to kiss arse | |
39:47 | you continue the very French politics | |
39:51 | of the grand prostitute, | |
39:55 | because for decades France has been | |
39:59 | the grand prostitute who gives herself to the highest bidder. | |
40:03 | You will see how they will treat you, | |
40:07 | you the prostitute, you will see how Islam considers | |
40:11 | prostitutes, it’s exactly the contrary | |
40:15 | which you will reap. But let | |
40:19 | the events come. You know, I remember | |
40:23 | an intervention of mine in summer, when it was the beginning of the beginning, | |
40:27 | when one started to know that there were 2 or 3 | |
40:31 | 4, 5, 10 French, 4, 3, 5, 10 | |
40:35 | English who had joined ISIS | |
40:39 | at that moment (it’s on record). | |
40:43 | Your leaders lie to you; there are already thousands, | |
40:47 | but they don’t tell you. Look at what I said | |
40:51 | when no-one said it yet: “They lie to you”; | |
40:55 | there are already thousands. We had to wait | |
40:59 | only a few weeks, 1 or 2 months maximum until | |
41:03 | governments said “yes it’s true, there are thousands…” | |
41:07 | of French, there are thousands of English, there are thousands of Europeans | |
41:11 | who joined ISIS in Syria and Iraq. You want me to tell you something? | |
41:15 | If they owned up to “thousands”, listen to me, there are tens of thousands. | |
41:19 | The total collapse | |
41:23 | of the politics of assimilation in France. | |
41:27 | Total, there is no greater failure, | |
41:31 | but they will never tell you this, they do not want you to panic, they do not want to tell you | |
41:35 | the truth that if you walk the streets of France you don’t know any longer who | |
41:39 | you will meet today. And you don’t even know | |
41:43 | if you can enter a shop, a café, visit the Eiffel Tower or the Arc de Triomphe, | |
41:47 | because they will not warn you when they | |
41:51 | know that it will blow up, they will continue to put you to sleep, | |
41:55 | because, anyway, it’s too late, so as I said, | |
41:59 | unfortunately today’s politics is: better to die while asleep | |
42:04 | than die while awake, because in any case we will die. | |
42:08 | There is no turning back | |
42:12 | it has been too long, too long, | |
42:16 | that European politics has been a politics of prostitution. | |
42:20 | Hoping for better days, but the | |
42:24 | prostitute will be stoned to death by those | |
42:28 | whom she thought to seduce, and by those | |
42:32 | of whom she thought she was being loved. | |
42:36 | You will see. Now, the presence | |
42:40 | of our head of state at such a demonstration | |
42:44 | is horrible, it’s unforgivable, | |
42:48 | it’s unacceptable. I’m not privy to his little secrets, | |
42:52 | to know if he knew at whose side he was going to demonstrate. | |
42:56 | You understand, of course, that it’s not the personage | |
43:00 | who disturbs me by his presence, it’s the message | |
43:04 | which Europe and especially the French Government wanted to spread via | |
43:08 | his presence or thanks to his presence. What did our (leader) | |
43:12 | do over there. Well, | |
43:16 | sincerely I am so disgusted, so disappointed, so | |
43:20 | shocked as, I think, are thousands | |
43:24 | of Jews in the world, especially Israeli Jews, | |
43:28 | that…I don’t know…I have no answer. | |
43:32 | I have no answer. | |
43:36 | Is this disease so grave that even here, | |
43:40 | where it was to be expected the least, one sees the ravages | |
43:44 | this disease? I don’t know. | |
43:48 | I can only tell you it’s disgusting, sickening, | |
43:52 | it’s abject. I can tell you | |
43:56 | I certainly will revise my position during the next elections | |
44:00 | here in Israel, lest we get an explanation | |
44:04 | so evident, so strong, so acceptable | |
44:08 | that publicly I will present my excuses publicly. | |
44:12 | But as I would be very surprised if we get an explanation, as several days have passed since, | |
44:16 | and we have still no explanation regarding his presence in France. | |
44:20 | I think that many, like myself, will revise their vote | |
44:24 | in March | |
44:28 | because being spat in the face like that | |
44:32 | will remain painful for a long time, and very difficult | |
44:36 | to clean up. However, | |
44:40 | I would, if I dare conclude, | |
44:44 | if a conclusion is possible. | |
44:48 | I think, my friends, | |
44:52 | the situation is very, very grave, | |
44:56 | as I have repeated in my different courses for some time. | |
45:00 | We are on the brink of a great catastrophe, | |
45:04 | and it’s not very Jewish to speak | |
45:08 | like this, even less Hasidic, but it’s more grave | |
45:12 | and criminal to continue to sleep and to | |
45:16 | maintain the sleep. I would like to address | |
45:20 | myself to the Jews of France and Europe. | |
45:24 | Unfortunately, I think that | |
45:28 | in the not too distant future the Jews of America and elsewhere will have to be addressed, also. | |
45:32 | For the moment let’s address the Jews of France, | |
45:36 | especially of France and Europe: Stop your sleep. | |
45:40 | we are at this moment in a period that | |
45:44 | is in every point identical with the period of the 1920s or 1930s | |
45:48 | in Europe. | |
45:52 | I hesitate, but you know | |
45:56 | France, a certain France, has already shown | |
46:00 | that she can also be a collaborator. You know | |
46:04 | the majority of French Jews | |
46:08 | in 1939-45 were arrested by the French police, | |
46:12 | not by the Nazi police. | |
46:17 | Collaboration is a French fact, | |
46:21 | and very French. Don’t trust | |
46:25 | your government, who promise you that the Republic | |
46:29 | will take care | |
46:33 | of its citizens. Don’t trust them, because | |
46:37 | those who don’t even use the historical memory | |
46:41 | to protect themselves, | |
46:45 | what could wake them up? Europe, the world | |
46:49 | has sold us already once; France more specifically | |
46:53 | has sold us already once; | |
46:57 | she will make no present to us the next time, | |
47:01 | no present. And the Republic | |
47:05 | certainly will protect her citizens, but | |
47:09 | you know during difficult moments, they are all citizens except | |
47:13 | the Jews. And France has already proven this. | |
47:17 | My maternal grandfather was a soldier, | |
47:21 | a French soldier decorated in the war 1914-18; | |
47:25 | he was even wounded during that war, | |
47:29 | but, when the French police came to arrest him, and he showed | |
47:33 | his decoration, they told him: “Dirty Jew, shut up.” | |
47:37 | You are but a (?), get out! Yes it’s | |
47:41 | the past, I hope that those who continue | |
47:45 | to think it’s the past will not need to | |
47:49 | remember the past when they are already in the trains which will take them to wherever, | |
47:53 | because it’s unavoidable. | |
47:57 | Europe and especially France will do nothing | |
48:01 | to protect her Jews in the moment where she herself | |
48:05 | has the knife at her throat. The first ones | |
48:09 | she will sell will be the Jews. It’s more than certain, | |
48:13 | and one does not have to be a prophet to know it. History | |
48:17 | will repeat itself, because History already repeats itself. | |
48:21 | Politically, | |
48:25 | the worst enemy of the Jews in the world, | |
48:29 | politically speaking, it’s France. | |
48:33 | Very little is needed for it to get down to | |
48:37 | much larger levels of the population, | |
48:41 | and who knows what the next stages are? | |
48:45 | Jews of France and Jews of Europe: leave before it’s too late. | |
48:49 | Don’t be taken for a ride, | |
48:53 | don’t be misled, stop sleeping. | |
48:57 | Of all the difficulties, the one to come to Israel will be | |
49:01 | the easiest of all. | |
49:05 | And one that very quickly will be transformed in a true | |
49:09 | success. But the other difficulties which wait for you, | |
49:13 | if you stay will end in the trains | |
49:17 | and in death. Don’t listen any longer | |
49:21 | to those who promise you a better future. | |
49:25 | I would like to conclude by addressing myself to | |
49:29 | the Jewish community leaders | |
49:33 | in France and elsewhere, to those responsible for the communities | |
49:37 | to the Rabbis: How much longer | |
49:41 | will you hold your communities hostage? | |
49:45 | How much longer will you lie to them? Until when | |
49:49 | will you continue to be, knowingly or not, | |
49:54 | associated with | |
49:58 | ||
50:02 | what is happening and will happen? | |
50:06 | Until when? Until when? | |
50:10 | Your duty as Rabbi, as community leader, | |
50:14 | is to set an example, to prepare for your arrival here | |
50:18 | with all your communities. And you have | |
50:22 | the capacity and the means to do this. | |
50:26 | You no longer have the right to silence, | |
50:30 | or worse, to lie. Silence when you don’t take a position, | |
50:34 | or to lie when you make believe to your community that all will go well. | |
50:38 | No, all will go very badly. | |
50:42 | And if you don’t realise this, it’s even worse. | |
50:46 | Then you are not a community leader who has to be capable | |
50:50 | of seeing the long term. And long term, not to say | |
50:54 | medium term, or unfortunately short term | |
50:58 | You must take your communities and come here. | |
51:02 | Europe doesn’t want her Jews any longer. | |
51:06 | France does not want her Jews any longer, even if the official discourse is different. | |
51:10 | France does nothing to protect her Jews, she will | |
51:14 | do nothing once the knife is even closer to her throat. | |
51:18 | France will do nothing, so leave! | |
51:22 | Leave while you still can. Don’t be like those Jews who | |
51:26 | remained in Europe in the thirties, | |
51:30 | in 1935. Be like those | |
51:34 | who left when it was still possible. | |
51:38 | Stop your folly to believe that 3500 | |
51:42 | years of suffering and oppression – and you still believe | |
51:46 | that… but when will you wake up? | |
51:50 | Today you have a country, you have a state, you have the possibility | |
51:54 | today to lift up your head and to know at least | |
51:58 | why you fight, why you put yourself in danger, and even why you might | |
52:02 | die perhaps, but at least with dignity, | |
52:06 | as a man, not as | |
52:10 | a coward, not as a weakling | |
52:14 | not as an exile, sick of this disease of exile | |
52:18 | from which he will not heal. Leave before | |
52:22 | it’s too late. |
People, the lights are going out! The cassandras are shouting the warnings. Most won’t heed them. Instead you hear from the superficially learned “it will never happen again.” Meanwhile the wise say that the only lesson we learn from history is that we learn nothing from history.
Nobody can learn anything useful from history as it is normally written and marketed.
Perhaps 95% of histories are written by leader worshipping yellow journalists who lie both by omission and by fabricating as much history as they can get away with, whilst at the same time ensuring that whatever fables they cook up conform to the official line as determined by the dominant political cult of the day.
A person who can examine historical evidence realistically, such as Diana West, is too rare a phenomenon.
That is why we learn nothing useful from history.
Just watched the full 45min video. Absolutely dynamite.
What a terrific speech. Given out of love for Europe. Thanks, Ned!
How accurate- how sad… They’ll have to learn on the streets what we already know.