The Center for Security Policy has organized the sending of a letter to United States senators backing their stance on President Obama’s “framework agreement” with Iran. The text of the letter is below, included in a CSP press release. Full disclosure: I’m one of the more than 150 signatories to this letter.
Over 150 National Security Experts, Concerned Citizens Express Gratitude to Sen. Tom Cotton and Colleagues for Leadership on Iran
Washington, DC— Today, over 150 national security experts, former Senior military and government leaders, public policy practitioners and other American patriots have written to Sen. Tom Cotton (R-Arkansas) and 46 other United States Senators. They expressed their gratitude for the letter they wrote to the Iran’s leaders serving notice on them that in accordance with the United States Constitution, any agreement between President Obama and Ayatollah Khamenei reach on Iran’s nuclear program will be considered to be only an executive agreement that can be revoked by the next president or modified by congress — unless it is approved by the legislative branch.
The letter, organized by the Center for Security Policy, states in part:
“Given the chimerical nature of the so-called framework agreement — which is, at the moment, being characterized in wildly different ways by the various parties, raising profound uncertainty about the nature and extent of the commitments Iran is making, their actual value in preventing an Iranian nuclear weapons program, the timing and extent of sanctions relief, etc. — the need for congressional oversight, advice and consent concerning any accord that flows from that agreement can no longer responsibly be denied.“
“It would be a serious affront to the Constitution and to the American people were an agreement of this potentially enormous strategic consequence not to be submitted for such action by the Congress. Grievous insult would be added to injury should the United Nations Security Council instead be asked to approve it.”
Among the signatories of the letter were:
Lt. Gen. William G. Boykin, USA (Ret.), Former Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Intelligence
Admiral James A. Lyons, USN (Ret.), Former Commander-in-Chief, U.S. Pacific Fleet
Lt. Gen. Dave Deptula, USAF (Ret.), Former Chief, Air Force Intelligence, Surveillance and Reconnaissance
Ambassador Henry F. Cooper, Former Director of the Strategic Defense Initiative, Chief U.S. Negotiator to the Geneva Defense and Space Talks
Ambassador Eric M. Javits (Ret.), PermRep and Ambassador to the Conference on Disarmament, Organization for Prohibition of Chemical Weapons
Hon. Joseph E. Schmitz, Former Inspector General of the Department of Defense
Andy McCarthy, Former Chief Assistant United States Attorney, Southern District of New York
Hon. J. Kenneth Blackwell, Former U.S. Ambassador, U.N. Human Rights Commission
Lt. Col. M.L. “Buzz” Hefti, USMC (Ret.), Former Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense, Legislative Affairs
Kenneth deGraffenreid, Former Special Assistant to the President for National Security Affairs; Former Deputy Undersecretary of Defense for Policy; Former Deputy National Counterintelligence Executive
Oliver “Buck” Revell, Former Associate Deputy Director — Investigations, Federal Bureau of Investigation; Chairman, Board of Directors, Middle East Media Research Institute (MEMRI)
Gary Bauer, Christians United for Israel
Michael Ledeen, Freedom Scholar, Foundation for Defense of Democracies
Matthew Brooks, Executive Director, Republican Jewish Coalition
Frank J. Gaffney, Jr., President & CEO of the Center for Security Policy and a signatory to the letter, stated:
“Today, as the Senate Foreign Relations Committee considers whether the Senate must perform its constitutional duty as a check-and-balance on international agreements that can have far-reaching national security implications, it is to be hoped that the panel’s members will by guided by the open letter to the Iranian leadership signed by Senator Tom Cotton and forty-six of his colleagues. The appreciation expressed for that letter by over 150 Americans, who share a commitment to the common defense and concern about the defects of President Obama’s so-called ‘framework agreement,’ is a reminder that millions of our countrymen are counting on their elected representatives in Congress to perform quality-control on the executive branch’s deeply problematic conduct of the negotiations with Iran.”
The full text of the letter, with signatures, can be found below.
14 April 2015
Hon. Tom Cotton
United States Senate
B-33 Russell Senate Office Building
Washington, DC 20510
Dear Senator Cotton:
Each passing day seems to bring new and worrying revelations about the “framework agreement” that President Obama claims to have achieved with the Islamic Republic of Iran and five other nations. This “deal” is supposed to determine future restrictions on Iran’s nuclear ambitions. The cumulative effect of these insights is a powerful affirmation of the effort you and forty-six of your Senate colleagues made last month to put the mullahs on notice that any such deal would require congressional assent. We write to commend you for taking this important initiative.
In particular, we want to thank you for the American civics lesson you gave the Iranian leaders with this cautionary note: “…We will consider any agreement regarding your nuclear-weapons program that is not approved by the Congress as nothing more than an executive agreement between President Obama and Ayatollah Khamenei. The next president could revoke such an executive agreement with the stroke of a pen and future Congresses could modify the terms of the agreement at any time.” Your courageous warning bespoke a patriotic commitment to our Constitution and its separation of powers that is deeply appreciated.
Given the chimerical nature of the so-called framework agreement — which is, at the moment, being characterized in wildly different ways by the various parties, raising profound uncertainty about the nature and extent of the commitments Iran is making, their actual value in preventing an Iranian nuclear weapons program, the timing and extent of sanctions relief, etc. — the need for congressional oversight, advice and consent concerning any accord that flows from that agreement can no longer responsibly be denied.
It would be a serious affront to the Constitution and to the American people were an agreement of this potentially enormous strategic consequence not to be submitted for such action by the Congress. Grievous insult would be added to injury should the United Nations Security Council instead be asked to approve it.
Again we thank you for your leadership in ensuring that the constitutionally mandated process for assuring quality-control on international agreements is followed in this case. We urge you and your colleagues to insist on nothing less going forward.
cc: 46 other signatories of the Cotton Letter
Frank J. Gaffney, Jr.
President & CEO
Center for Security Policy
Lt. Gen. William G. Boykin
U.S. Army (Ret.)
Former Deputy Under Secretary of
Defense for Intelligence
Lt. Col. M. L. “Buzz” Hefti USMC (Ret.)
Former Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense,
Legislative Affairs
Admiral James A. Lyons USN (Ret.)
Former Commander-in-Chief,
U.S. Pacific Fleet
Andy McCarthy
Former Chief Assistant United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
Fred Fleitz
Senior Vice President for Policy & Programs
Center for Security Policy
Clare Lopez
Vice President of Research & Analysis
Center for Security Policy
Lt. Gen. Dave Deptula, USAF (Ret.)
Former Chief
Air Force Intelligence, Surveillance and Reconnaissance
Lt. Col. Roy White (Ret.)
Chapter Coordinator
ACT! for America, San Antonio
Ambassador Eric M. Javits (Ret.)
PermRep and Ambassador to the Conference on Disarmament
Organization for Prohibition of Chemical Weapons
Ambassador Henry F. Cooper
Former Director of the Strategic Defense Initiative
Chief U.S. Negotiator to the Geneva Defense and Space Talks
Admiral Tom Hayward USN (Ret.)
Honorable Allen B. Clark
Former Assistant Secretary
Department of Veterans Affairs
Hon. Joseph E. Schmitz
Former Inspector General of the Department of Defense
Hon. J. Kenneth Blackwell
Former U.S. Ambassador
U.N. Human Rights Commission
Hon. Thomas W. O’Connell
Former Assistant Secretary
Defense (Special Operations)
Kenneth deGraffenreid
Former Special Asst. to the President,
For National Security Affairs, Reagan
Fmr Deputy Undersecretary of Defense, Policy
Fmr Deputy National Counterintelligence Executive
Richard A. Viguerie
Chairman
ConservativeHQ.com
Jay W. Dickey, Jr.
Former U.S. Representative
Fourth Congressional District, Arkansas
George Rasley
Editor
Conservative HQ.com
Allen Roth
Secure America Now
Scott Brauer
Navy SEAL Officer (Ret.)
Dr. Steve Greer
CSM, USA (Ret.)
Charles L. Sues
Colonel USA (Ret.)
Warren Elliott
Former Officer Lt., USN
Bob Rohrer
U.S. Marine Veteran
Russell Thomas
U.S. Army
Rachel’s Children International
Bruce Brotman
Former Senior Executive at FBI
Former Senior Executive at TSA
Wayne Ronald Boyles, III
Former Senior Legislative Assistant
the Late U.S. Senator Jesse Helms
C. Preston Noell III
President
Tradition, Family, Property, Inc.
Roger Noriega
Former Assistant Secretary of State
Western Hemisphere Affairs
Matthew Brooks
Executive Director
Republican Jewish Coalition
Noah Silverman
Congressional Affairs Director
Republican Jewish Coalition
David J. Frum
Author and Commentator
Starr Pitzer
President
Pitzer Group, Inc.
Tom Trento
Director
The United West
Rick Manning
President
Americans for Limited Government
Elaine Donnelly
President
Center for Military Readiness
Dr. Daniel Goure
Vice President
Lexington Institute
Morton Klein
National President
Zionist Organization of America
Daniel Pollak
Co-Director Government Relations
Zionist Organization of America
Joshua London
Co-Director Government Relations
Zionist Organization of America
Floyd W. “Wink” McKinnon
President
Cotswold Industries, Inc.
Seton Motley
Founder & President
Less Government
Oliver “Buck” Revell
Former Associate Deputy Director — Investigations
Federal Bureau of Investigation
Chairman, Board of Directors
Middle East Media Research Institute (MEMRI)
Andrew Bostom, MD
Author, “The Legacy of Jihad”
“Iran’s Final Solution for Israel”
Robert Jackall
Willmott Family Professor
Williams College
Alice Linahan
Vice President
Women On The Wall
Judy Taibi
President
Ingenuity Partners
Phyllis Kaminsky
Former Director
United Nations Information Center
Stuart Kaufman
Coordinator of Special Operations, The United West
Columnist, Charleston Mercury
Jack David
Senior Fellow, Hudson Institute
Former Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense
Combating Weapons of Mass Destruction & Negotiations Policy
Nicholas F.S. Papanicolaou
Author and Worldwide Leader
Sovereign Order of Saint John of Jerusalem,
Knights of Malta
Dr. Daniel Pipes
President
Middle East Forum
Daria Novak
President
Institute for American Politics
Penny Nancy
President
Concerned Women for America
J. L. Jackson
CEO (Ret.)
Fortune 500 Corporation
Morton Blackwell
Chairman
The Weyrich Lunch
Walter P. Stern
Chairman Emeritus
The Hudson Institute
Diana West
Journalist and Author
“American Betrayal: The Secret Assault
on Our Nation’s Character”
Ron Woodard
Director
NC Listen
Dee Hodges
President
Maryland Taxpayers Association
Linda Loomis, P.A.
Realtor
John R. Wood Properties
George A. Keyworth, II
Science Advisor to the President
(1981-1986)
Paula A. DeSutter
Assistant Secretary of State
Verification and Compliance (2002-2009)
Dr. Jack A. Milavic
US Army Retired
FFA and DOS Retired
Jeffrey W. Bayard
Publisher
Right Side News
Norman Jenulis
Retired Wall Street VP
Dr. Elie D. Krakowski
Former Special Assistant to
U.S. Assistant Secretary of Defense
Diana Denman
Former Reagan Appointee
Steven W. Mosher
President
Population Research Institute
Jen Bawden
Task Force on National and Homeland Security
Committee of the Secure the Grid Coalition
Jerome R. Corsi, Ph.D.
Senior Staff Write, WMD.com
Author, “ATOMIC IRAN: How the Terrorist Regime
Bought the Bomb and American Politicians”
Janet Lehr
Editor and Publisher
IsraelLives.org
Mitchell Counts
Associate Professor of Law
Belmont University College of Law
John Wohlstetter
Senior Fellow
Discovery Institute
London Center for Policy Research
G. William Heiser
Director, Arms Control Policy
National Security Council Staff
Mona Charen
Syndicated Columnist
Senior Fellow, Ethics and Public Policy Center
Irving W. Ginsberg, Ph.D.
Retired Chief Scientist
Dept. of Energy’s Remote Sensing Laboratory
Former Member of Nuclear Emergency Search Team (NEST)
Donna Laquintano
Assistant to Richard J. Fox
Stanley J. Horky
Manager and Owner
Program Initiatives, LLC
Scott Franklin
Franklin Consulting Works
Russell J. Ramsland, Jr.
Leader
Park Cities/Preston Hollow Leadership Forum
Michael G. Hoehn, Esq.
Executive Director
Alliance for Vigilance
Sidney Powell
Attorney
Lawrence Kogan
CEO
Institute for Trade, Standards and
Sustainable Development (ITSSD)
Jack Park
Attorney
Judson Phillips
Founder
Tea Party Nation
Ron Robinson
President
Young American’s Foundation
Brigitte Gabriel
Founder & CEO
ACT for America
Sarah Hart
Former Chapter Leader
ACT! for America, Pittsburgh
Debra Burlingame
Co-Founder
9/11 Families for a Safe & Strong America
Kristin Fecteau
Co-Founder
Campaign to Free America
Michael James Barton
Former Middle East Policy Deputy Director
The Pentagon
Melissa Ortiz
Founder and Principal
Able American
William H. Shaker
President
Rule of Law Committee
Ronald D. Rotunda
The Doy & Dee Henley Chair and
Distinguished Professor of Jurisprudence
Chapman University
Gail Madden
Former Mayor Pro Tem
Highland Park, Texas
Roger Simon
President
PJ Media
David Webb
Sirius XM Patriot Talk Show Host
Scott Bradford
Owner
Bradford Rx Solutions, LLC
Joel Pollak
Editor-in-Chief and In-House Counsel
Breitbart.com
George Landrith
President
Frontiers of Freedom
Diana Furchtgott-Roth
Manhattan Institute
Clarice Feldman
Writer and Lawyer
The American Thinker
Janet Parshall
National Syndicated Talk Show Host
Rock Peters
Freelance writer
Knights of Columbus
Carol Tabor
President
Family Security Matters
Abigail Thernstrom
Adjunct Scholar
American Enterprise Institute
John Hinderaker
Powerline
Colin Hanna
President
Let Freedom Ring
Andrew Hyman
Executive Director
The Institute for Intermediate Study (IFIS)
Lucinda Demick
Army & Air Force Exchange Services
Bill Bennett
National Talk Radio Host
Gary Bauer
Christians United for Israel
Chuck Muth
President
Citizen Outreach
Wilma Hall
Former White House National Security Secretary
Stephen Bryen
Former Undersecretary of Defense
For Trade Security Policy
Mary Beth Long
Former Assistant Secretary of Defense
James Roche
Former Secretary of the AF
Jim and Judy Warner
Former POW Vietnam
Lori Lowenthal Marcus
Correspondent
Jewish Week
Richard Falknor
Publisher
Blue Ridge Forum
Susan Falknor
Publisher
Blue Ridge Forum
James Simpson
Freelance Journalist
Sandy Rios
Director of Government Affairs
American Family Association
Carol Greenwald
Former Commissioner of Banking
Massachusetts
Michael Ledeen
Freedom Scholar
Foundation for Defense of Democracies
A. Baron Cass, III
American Citizen
Darlene G. Cass
American Citizen
R.H. Pickens
American Citizen
Steven T. Carter
American Citizen
Russ Miller
American Citizen
Joy Miller
American Citizen
Mr. Steven Stern
American Citizen
Rael and Erich Isaac
Authors
Ned May
American Citizen
Orna Shulman
American Citizen
Matthew Landau
American Citizen
Magaly Jenulis
American Citizen
Pamela J. Jones
American Citizen
Fred A. Reitman, Ph.D., DABT
American Citizen
Judith M. O’Donnell, Ph.D.
American Citizen
Joseph T. Doyle, M.D.
American Citizen
Chris and Tammy Kreif
American Citizens
Sofia Gallo
Princeton University
Theodore Furchtgott
Princeton University
Allison Berger
Princeton University
Noga Zaborowski
Princeton University
Kathleen McCreary
American Citizen
Donna Soloway
American Citizen
Karon Franklin
American Citizen
Elaine Conti
American Citizen
Rita O. Geismar
American Citizen
Anna Haim
American Citizen
Barbara McKinnon
American Citizen
Cynthia Grubb
American Citizen
Dennis Grubb
American Citizen
Dina Lewis
American Citizen
A letter was sent, but what as congress actually done at this point?
American Citizen
should I send money and if so, where to? Ungrammatical, I know. It’s early. More coffee.
Check and see if the Center for Security Policy has a “donate” button. I know they accept donations; they’re a 501c(3).
How much of a problem is it that the committee’s 19-0 vote to bring the bill forward deleted the “no terrorism” phrase? Maybe Iran is no worse than Cuba?
http://www.breitbart.com/big-government/2015/04/14/senators-wont-force-obama-to-certify-iran-has-refrained-from-terrorist-acts/
I think the idea is that they’re supposedly no worse than Saudi Arabia or Qatar which also fund terrorist groups. Besides, don’t you know that one man’s terrorist is another man’s freedom fighter? Regardless, excuses are always made for other countries so why not Iran?
The main thing I’m concerned about is that I don’t think congress will be able to do anything to stop this even with a supermajority.
http://www.centerforsecuritypolicy.org/2015/04/15/a-formula-for-rubber-stamping-obamas-iran-deal/
“The President and his partisans on Capitol Hill are on board for a simple reason: Instead of this deal facing the high hurdle the Constitution requires for treaties – in which the executive branch must persuade two-thirds of the Senate to approve it, the mechanism set up by the proposed legislation will require opponents to come up with that super-majority in both houses of Congress.”
All I can say is, from Iran’s playbook:
“Did they secure Allah’s scheme/deceit ? So no(one) trusts Allah’s scheme/deceit except the nation the losers.” Qur’an Text/Transliteration 7:99
Excellent Job!